Research Summary of the 2007 IACFS Conference
Compiled by Dr. Lesley Ann Fein MD, MPH
1. Dr. Paul Cheney-Mayo Clinic
-- CFS patients have increased metHb, increase G6PD as a response to tissue
hypoxia. They also have decreased cardiac output which is not just due to
positional changes, i.e. worse while lying.
--- The cardiac index of CFS patients is so severe it falls between the value
of patients with MI and those in shock
--- CFS patients have congestive heart failure but mostly diastolic failure.
The LV doesn’t fill well and it squeezes really hard to get the blood out.
(Probably much worse since CFS patients have a low blood volume
2. Dr. Richard A Van Konynenburg
--Estrogen increases oxidative stress thus explaining predominance of
--Also reports studies by Cheney that 50-80% of 2,000 patients with CFS
benefited from high doses of B12. Others found low B12and high homocysteine in
the CSF of CFS pts. Also folic acid improved energy in 81% pts. Other findings:
elevated proinflammatory cytokines, Th2 shift, low NK cells, carnitine
deficiency, gut problems.
--Reduced glutathione seen in CFS and Chronic LD
--Depletion of magnesium can cause mitochondria dysfunction, twitching,
muscle pain, sleep problems and cardiac symptoms.
--Loss of temperature regulation caused by low cardiac output which causes
autonomic nerve dysfunction and decrease blood flow to the skin.
--Lactulose breath test is abnormal indicating over growth also assoc. with
--Weight gain results from inability to metabolize carbs nd fats normally
because of blocks in krebs cycle due to decrease glutathione, carbs end up being
cycled back as fat
--Bottom line: supplement with B12, folic acid, glutathione
3. Dr. Martin Lerner
-- States that all CFS patients have abnormal T waves. Inversions seen in
96%. Also have resting tachycardia. Cardiac bx show fibrosis, myofiber disarray
and fatty infiltrates.
-- Did studies with Valacyclovere which were better for EBV but Valcyte
better for CMV. Improved cardiac function as well as fatigue. Also 6 month
-- Safety issues: drink 6-8 glasses of water a day. Monitor cbc and chem..
---Another cardiac study: Javierre et al (Univ of Barcelona)
-- Workload is 52% higher in normals than CFS and oxygen uptake is 47.5%
higher but similar duration
4. Dr. Vance Spence (ME Res. UK)
-- CFS patients vs controls had higher CRP’s, higher 8-iso-prostaglandin
F2alpha which correlate with “arterial stiffness”
-- He questions the role of neutrophil elastase. Quotes article by Van Putte
et al in Pediatrics 2005
FATIGUE AND EXERCISE
5. Dr. Barry Hurwitz (University of Miami)
--Documented low rbc and low blood volume in CFS. Also low rbc correlates
with high IL6, ESR and CRP. Epogen did not improve clinical symptoms despite
raising the rbc. Total tilt duration was not different between treated and
controls but was different in those with the greatest increase in rbc,
indicating a lower risk of syncope in that group.
6. Margaret Cicolella California
--Abnormal ETT in CFS: decrease peak V02, atypical recovery response, post
Poster: Ruud et al –Rotterdam-rv
--Prolonged physical performance improved aerobic capacity in normal people
but resulted in a lower anaerobic threshold and a state of malaise that is
comparable to overtraining
Poster: Mark Van Ness-Pacific fatigue lab, CA
--Metabolic and immune response to exercise in CFS
--Significant metabolic abnormalities in CFS: low peak workload, low peak
ventilation, low peak oxygen consumption, low O2 consumption at anaerobic
Poster: Alegre, Martin
--Activated elastase and monovytes RNAse, exercise induced decreased
functional reserve, decreased peak aerobic power (can be cause of muscle
Poster: Staci Stevens-Pacific fatigue lab
-- Post exertional malaise following exercise challenge. Fatigue,
lightheadedness, vertigo, joint pain, muscle pain, cognitive dysfunction,
headache, nausea, trembling, instability, sore throats and glands.
Poster: Dr. Rich Konyenburg
-- Compelling evidence that glutathione depletion important part of
pathogenesis of CFS
7. Dr. Garth Nicolson
-- Fatigue is caused by damage to the mitochondria thus impairing their
ability to make ATP and NADH. Increased metHb is also a marker for oxidative
--Rx: NT Factor decreases fatigue by 35-45%
--For cancer: Propax+NT Factor reduce chemo side effects by 70%
8. Dr. Jacob Teitlebaum (Annapolis, Maryland)
-- CFS and FM pts have decreased ATP. Ribose increases tissue ATP.
---Rx: 5g Ribose 3 times a day mixed with food or beverage improved sleep,
energy. Mental clarity, pain and well being.
9. Ulf Hannestad
-- Brain amino acid dysfunction in CFS (Karolinska Institue)
--Arginine-ornithine-putrescene-spermidine-spermine: latter two inhibit NK
cells and T lymphocytes
-- Postulates that organisms could fuel the process by increasing ornithine
10. Watanabe and Tajima Osaka City Medical School
-- Sleep disturbances which could potentially respond to
--- CoQ10, Vitamin B1, Aloha Lipoic Acid, L-Carnitine
11. Dr. N. Porter (female)
-- Defined 5 types of fatigue:
12. Dr. Elizabeth Maloney (CDC – Emory University School of Psychiatry)
-- CFS have high allostatic load predisposes to metabolic syndrome due to
13. Dr. Joan Shaver – University of Illinois
-- Sleep disorders in CFS. Also 10-15% of normal population have sleep
disorders. Stages: 1: 5-10%, 2: 40-50% (light), 3&4; 20% deep/delta, REM 20-25%
-- Need to establish a routine. Initially sleep restriction, i.e. force
patients to stay awake all day until bedtime. Restated that there is decreased
growth hormone production in CFS during sleep (this was also documented in FM,
as well as decreased exercise response in FM, i.e. normal pts increase GH after
exercise, but FM pts failed to respond). In hyperactive people, need to find
something that dampens their cognitive arousal. Dark also NB.
-- Her slides are phenomenal but didn’t present all the data. Discusses
overlap between FM and other syndromes. Neurophysiologic pathways. Genetic
factors. Subgroups in FM. Causes of widespread hyperalgesia. Functional
MRimaging comparing normal and FM brains.
GENERAL SLEEP CONCEPTS
-- RLS restless legs occurs before sleep
--- PLMS periodic limb movements occur during sleep
-- NM Nocturnal myoclonus
-- Dysania: foggy, stiff, sore in the morning
-- Alpha intrusion: “awake waves” that intrude during light sleep (stage 2)
-- UARS Upper Airway Resistance Syndrome. This is like a step down from
sleep apnea. Associated with low PO2, fatigue, IBS etc. This syndrome DOES
respond to CPAP whereas sleep apnea did not.
--- “Tired but wired”PAIN
14. Dr. Karen Berkley (Florida State Univ)
--- Talked about the “pain matrix” in the brain, and the fact that FM
patients react differently to pain. Talked about estrogen playing a role in
processing of pain at the spinal cord level. Female rats tolerated distension of
the bladder and uterus differently depending upon the estrogen level.
15. Dr. Jin Mann S. Lin (CDC)
--Looked at subgroups who do not fit criteria for CFS, called ISF. One third
of ISF were similar to CFS but did not meet criteria for CFS.
16. Dr. Han Kang (DC VAH)
--CFS in Gulf War Vets 10 years later. 5,000 gulf war vets vs. 3400 other
vets: 5% GW vets had CFS in 1995 0.9% in other vets had CFS
--After 10 years: another 8% GW vets had CFS
--Of the ones who were positive in 1995, 71% were better after 10 years.
17. Dr. Rosemary Underhill (Kings College Hosp. in London)
--CFS in offspring of mothers with CFS. 16% of kids had either CFS or CF.
-- 24% mothers had at least one kid with CFS/CF
BRAIN FUNCTION SESSION
18. Dr. Paul Nestadt (Sinai)
-- Neuroimaging looking at brain metabolites found that significantly higher
lactate level in brain . Differences in hippocampal glutamate differentiated
between CFS with and without depression. Also decreased NAA which can mean
either decreased neuron density or decreased metabolism. They assume it is
decreased metabolism. Also assume brain goes into anaerobic metabolism
19. Dr. Garcia Quintana (Brussels)
-- Brain SPECT in CFS: high prevalence of cortical uptake abnormalities in
common areas. Correlates with markers: mostly RNAse, and less with elastase
-- Also did SPECT after stress test: exercise followed by frontal
stimulation showed decreased uptake in all places but mostly wernicke region
20. Dr. Fumihara Togo (UMDNJ)
-- Accuracy rate of CFS same as controls when control for motor response time
and information processing time
21. Dr. HIROHIKO KURATSUNE - Osaka City University School of medicine
-- “Brain Dysfunction is a key abnormality for understanding the state of
-- Ties together the concepts of stress, immune dysfunction, infections all
impacting on brain function. Shows abnormal brain MRI’s.
-- Correlates brain volume with performance status.
-- Shows abnormal SPECT scans in CFS. Looks at acetylcarnitine uptake in
-- Administered acetylcarnitine to rats and then ground up the brains to
show metabolites in brain samples (not sure if this is part of the serum testing
he does on patients)
-- shows reduced binding of 5-HTP in CFS brains
-- Next looks at PET scans: big difference between CFS and normal
-- Does a serum assay which differentiates normal from CFS (cant read slide
but he identifies substances in serum not found in any normals)
-- Presented slide of the neuro-molecular mechanism leading to chronic
-- willing to collaborate and get serum samples from our patients.
23. Dr. Eleanor Stein (Calgary, Canada)
-- CBT and graded exercise therapy study -- Both improve fatigue but exercise
does not improve exercise capacity in CFS but less than half the studies show
decrease in pain, mood or health in both CFS and FM.
--- CBT is not better than group programs.
23. Dr. Garcia Fructuoso (Barcelona)
-- Showed very specific sets of SNP’s in patients vs controls
24. Dr. Lisa Cannon-Albright (Utah) NIH grant recipient
-- Found that relatives of CFS patients with CFS had higher genetic
relatedness than would be expected. In Utah group, 13 had infectious onset and
11 had non infectious onset. Also states that estrogen improves symptoms
(estrogen therapy and pregnancy)
25. PAPER: BEGONA CASADA AND JAMES BARANIUK
-- Proteomic biosignature of CFS in CSF
-- Unbelievable finding of completely unique markers in the CSF, completely
absent from control group.
-- Alpha 2 macroglobulin (anti-protease)
-- Orosomucoid 2 (anti-protease)
-- Keratin 16 (? Assoc with meningeal lining)
-- Pigment epithelial derived factor (assoc with vascular dysregulation,
--BEHAB (assoc with structural repair)
--CDC-subspace clustering Clustering of SNPs mostly related to cortisol,
--Genetic markers for alzheimers, hypothalamic pituitary axis, glucocorticoid
--Some genes correlated directly with specific symptoms.
26. Dr. Jonathan Kerr et al (St Georges Univ of London)
--Q Fever-DRB1-11-low gamma interferon and IL2
--Parvo B19-DRB1-01/04-pos RF
-- 7 genes upregulated in CFS: apoptosis, pesticides, mitochondrial,
demyelination, viral binding sites
-- Has a nice diagram of causality regarding infections and CFS
27. Dr. Toni Whistler (CDC, South African)
-- PIFS: Post Infectious Fatigue Syndrome
-- Q fever, Ross River syndrome, EBV in Australia
-- Selective expression of 256 genes involved in metabolic and regulatory
pathways. Severity of acute infection correlated with progression to PIFS
28. Dr. Andreas Kogelnik et al (Stanford)
-- Valgancyclovere (Valcyte-Roche) in patients with high titers to HHV6 and
EBV who had been sick for one year or more, treated for 6 months. 75% success
rate. People went from 5-25% level of functioning to 70-90% level of functioning
and had sustained improvement. Patients felt worse in first 2 weeks (Herx-like
31. Japanese presenter-didn’t get name.
-- HSV1 stimulated by UV light, hyperthermia and stress
HHV6A and B
-- B causes roseola infantum, becomes latent in macrophages in brain, causes
febrile seizures if reactivated.
-- Can do PCR on saliva
-- Saliva HHV6 saliva viral load correlates with “hard work”
-- More HHV7 in CFS with psychiatric disorder
-- Herpes viruses all sit inside of macrophages in the parotid and salivary
glands and remain latent until the immune system is challenged and then they
--Used “anti-fatigue substance” which substantially improved energy in these
patients. This was D Ribose.
29. Dr. Ronald Glaser- Ohio State University
--Chronic fatigue syndrome and viral latency.
-- “Stress is the confusion created when one’s mind overrides the body’s
basic desire to choke the living daylights out of some jerk who desperately
-- Stress increases cortisol releasing hormone which increases ACTH which
stimulates increase in cortisol production
-- Also talks about immune cells (B and T lymphocytes) having receptors for
glucocorticoids, serotonin, growth hormone, substance P, prolactin
-- Also looked at lymphocyte function in medical students before exams and
after vacations. After vacation had 18,000 IFN U/ml, before exams went down to
888. Also had reduced memory T cell response before exams, and reduced T cell
killing by B cells before exams.
-- In patients with normal immune systems you do not have to get a rise in
titer when there is virus reactivation, however showed that med students had
higher EBV VCA antibody titers, and higher herpes simplex I AB before exams than
-- Also discussed grave concern about astronauts getting reactivation of
EBV, CMV, Varicella Zoster when they remain in space for too long.
-- EBV EA roteins are made early in the infection and are proteins that do
not require viral DNA. Viral proteins induce transformation of monocytes to
-- EBV encoded dUTPase modulates immune function and induces sickness
behaviour in mice.
-- Viral proteins induce TNF gamma and IL 6
30. Dr. Dharam Ablashi-HHV6 Foundation Santa Barbara, CA
-- Best assays for detecting reactivation of HHV6 and EBV.
--Highly Elevated antibodies to EBV VCA and highly elevated antibodies to HHV6
are useful indicators of reactivated infection. EA IgG is best indicator. RNAse
L Protein is a marker for active infection.
-- Two kinds of HHV6, A and B. A is neurotropic and B is not.
-- Other viruses implicated in CFS: stealth, enterovirus, foamy virus,
parvovirus, hep C, Ross, Rubella, Coxsackie, Borna
--Things that are anti-HHV6 are red marine dye, amantidine, lamictal.
32. Dr. Mary Fletcher -Miami VA Medical Center
--Gulf War vets and CFS patients have increased CD26 and CD2 T cells but
lower number of molecules per cell.
--Neuropeptide Y released during stress in GW victims.
31. Gurbaxani - CDC
-- Elevated IL 6 in CFS. Supports the hypothesis that an ongoing
pro-inflammatory response contributes to the CFS symptoms. Body Mass Index
correlates with IL 6 levels.
32. Marshall Williams-Ohio State University
--EBV encoded deoxyuridine triphosphate nucleotideohydrolase (dUTPase) is
expressed during lytic and possibly during abortive reactivation and induces
immune dysregulation and up-regulation of proinflammatory cytokines (TNF gamma,
IL 1b, IL 6, IL8) Also inhibits T cell blastogenesis. Target cells are
macrophages and dendritic cells. Induces “sick behaviour” in mice.
-- Looking at similar protein in HHV6. Suggest that viral proteins
responsible for more than just viral replication and play role in
pathophysiology of infection. They enhance proliferation of infected B cells and
activate endothelial cells. HHV6A activates latent EBV genomes in B cells.
34. Dr. Susan Levine NYC.
--Looked at 20 CFS vs controls. 45% CFS showed activation of EBV (EA IgG). No
--35% CFS had high titers to HHV6. No controls.
-- EBV VCA and EA up in 30% CFS, 8% controls
-- Positive HHV6 antigen in 20% CFS, no controls
35. Modra Murovska-Riga Stradins University-Riga
--Frequency of activation of both HHV6 and HHV7 higher in CFS patients
-- HHV6B variant predominant in CFS
-- Dual infection significantly decreased CD3+ and CD4+ cells
-- John Chia-EV Med Research, Lomita, CA IMPRESSIVE STUDY CFS associated with
persistant enterovirus infection in the gut. Did biopsies and found positive
staining for enterovirus in 80% of CFS patients! Only 5% positive for H. pylori.
Found enterovirus RNA in 33% of biopsies, and confirmed infections with positive
35. Garth Nicolson - Insititute for Molecular medicine, CA
-- Chronic bacterial co-infections in CFS and CFS subsequently diagnosed with
Lyme disease. In Western US 9% of CFS patients have positive Lyme testing. Other
bacteria: mycoplasma fermentans in 65%.
37. Dr. Anthony Komaroff Harvard medical School
-- Well documented that CFS develops in the wake of various infections: EBV,
Parvo B19, Enteroviruses, Ross River Virus, Borrelia burgdorferi, Coxiella
burnetti (Q fever), Mycoplasma species, HHV6.
-- The most robust immunological abnormalities found in CFS: activated CD8+,
poorly functioning NK cells, novel 2-5A binding protein(low molecular weight 25A
RNAse seen ONLY in CFS), dysregulated pro-inflammatory cytokines-these most
likely the cause for many of the symptoms in CFS.
1. IV Saline
-- Poster: Travis et al-pacific fatigue lab-Stockton, CA
1liter IV Saline improves physical functioning in CFS and improves peak V02,
HR and BP I response to exercise.
Poster: Garcia Fructouoso-barcelona
Use of Madafinil on daytime hypersomnia effective but side effects in 65%
3. .NT Factor
Poster: Garth Nicolson-Lipid replacement and antioxidant therapy for
restoring mitochondrial function in CFS
-- NT Factor replaces damaged mitochondrial lipids and resulted in increased
functioning vs controls. Needs continuous use for benefit to be sustained.
4. Lactic acid bacteria
-- Poster: Sullivan-Karolinska Institute- Sweden
Lactic acid bacteria improve fatigue (cultura dofilus natural yoghurt, alra
-- Poster: Daniel Blockmans-Belgium
-- Methylphenidate improved fatigue, concentration at 2x10mg a day
6. Pulse low dose IVIG/diet/exercise
-- Poster: Tae Park-Korea
-- IVIG 1g per week for 6 months with strict diet(organic food, no processed
foods or sugars, no chocolate, no hot pepper), sleep (Klonipin), ample hydration
and salt, and exercise control (no heavy lifting, no heavy house cleaning)showed
-- IVIG improved sleep apnea
-- Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker-MD
-- Tadalafil 20mg every 3 days for 5 doses reduced shortness of breath,
improved exercise tolerance
8. B12, folinic acid, glutathione. CoQ10, Vitamin B1, Aloha Lipoic Acid,
9. Valacyclovir which were better for EBV but Valcyte better for CMV. Improved
cardiac function as well as fatigue. Also 6 month studies.
--Safety issues: drink 6-8 glasses of water a day. Monitor cbc and chem..
10. D Ribose
-- Rx: 5g Ribose 3 times a day mixed with food or beverage improved sleep,
energy. Mental clarity, pain and well being.
11. Valgancyclovir (Valcyte-Roche) in patients with high titers to HHV6 and
Notes on 2007 IACFS Conference compiled and provided by
Lesley Ann Fein MD, MPH
Member: National Lyme Disease Community Caucus
Medical Director: Connectocut Lyme disease support and action group
Medical Director: Pennsylvania Lyme Disease Society
Dr. Lesley Ann Fein MD, MPH
1099 Bloomfield Ave
West Caldwell, NJ 07006